When the Lease Plan Disagrees With the Flat: Measuring Demised Premises Before Exchange
Photo: leasehold flat conversion London interior surveyor measuring rooms with laser distance meter, via wallpapers.com
The plan was never intended to be a survey
Most lease plans carry a version of the phrase 'for the purposes of identification only'. They are frequently not to scale. Some are traced from earlier documents, some are redrawn by a solicitor's assistant from a photograph, and some have been hand-amended over four decades of assignments. Treating such a drawing as an accurate description of a flat is a category error, and an expensive one when it surfaces after completion.
What the lease actually demises
The demise is the extent of property granted by the lease. It may include the flat itself, a store or bin store, a parking space, a garden or terrace, a balcony, a loft, a cellar, and rights of way over passages and staircases. It almost certainly excludes the structure — the roof, the external walls, the foundations — which remains with the freeholder. The plan is meant to show where the demise begins and ends. The flat shows what was actually built.
Where the two commonly part company
Bay windows are a familiar example. A plan may run a straight line across the front elevation, ignoring a bay that has been part of the habitable room since 1890. The buyer assumes the bay is included; the plan suggests otherwise; the freeholder's solicitors may take a different view again.
Stores in converted terraces are another. An allocated store in a rear passage may be numbered on the plan but not edged, or edged in the wrong place, or allocated by a schedule that has been lost. Parking bays raise the same problem, as do roof terraces and small areas of garden whose boundary has crept over the years.
Loft spaces deserve particular care. A flat may have enjoyed exclusive use of a loft for thirty years without that space being demised. Occupation is not ownership, and consistent use over time does not necessarily convert one into the other.
Shared access is the fourth recurring theme: a passage or entry that every resident uses daily, but which the plan shows as falling inside a neighbouring freehold, or outside the property altogether. Rights of way granted in the body of the lease may sit uneasily with a plan that contradicts them.
Conversion irregularities complete the list. Partitions in a converted Victorian house rarely align with the structural walls the plan assumes, and upper floors that oversail shared entrances create flying freeholds whose extent needs careful recording.
What to measure before exchange
| Item | How it is recorded | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Gross internal area | Internal face to internal face, room by room | Baseline against the plan and the particulars |
| Bay projections | Depth, width, height, window type | Often inside the flat but outside the plan |
| Store and bin store | Dimensions, door, position, numbering | Frequently demised but unedged |
| Garden or terrace | Boundary lengths, wall types, levels | Reveals encroachment and maintenance liability |
| Parking bay | Width, length, markings, obstruction | Allocation disputes are common |
| Shared access | Clear width at pinch points, thresholds | Rights of way must be usable |
| Loft or cellar | Head height, access, floor structure | Use is not the same as demise |
| Wall thicknesses | Measured at openings and returns | Reconciles measured area with the plan |
Reconciling the plan with what is there
The useful output of a measured audit is not an opinion about who is right. It is a schedule of discrepancies, expressed in millimetres, dated, photographed and annotated onto a copy of the lease plan. Each variance can then be sorted into one of three types: a drafting error in the plan, which may be correctable by a deed of rectification; a physical encroachment by a neighbour, which is a matter for the solicitors and possibly the insurers; or a discrepancy already resolved elsewhere in the deeds, in an assignment, a licence or a deed of variation.
That classification is what allows a buyer's solicitor to give practical advice rather than a general warning.
Why a marketing floorplan will not do
Floorplans produced for sales particulars serve a different purpose. They are usually drawn from a quick internal trace, they simplify wall thicknesses, they rarely extend to stores, gardens or parking, and they carry no information about rights, boundaries or demise. They are helpful for imagining furniture. They are not evidence.
Working alongside the conveyancer
A measured audit does not replace legal due diligence; it feeds it. The surveyor records what exists and where the plan departs from it. The solicitor decides what that means for the lease, the title and the freeholder's consent. Where a managing agent holds the definitive plan, the audit should be checked against it before exchange rather than after.
The cost of leaving it until later
Disputes over a store, a parking bay or a strip of garden tend to emerge at the worst possible moments — during a resale, on a remortgage, or when a neighbour extends. Resolving them retrospectively involves consent fees, licences, sometimes a deed of variation, and occasionally a reduction in value. Measuring before exchange costs a fraction of that, and it turns an assumption into a recorded fact.